Skip to main content
search

Insurance Companies

We represent a variety of insurance companies to better serve you.

Acuity

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Auto Owners Insurance

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Cincinnati

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

FCCI

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Goodville Affordable Insurance

General
Visit Website
Billing
Bill Pay

Grinnell

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Mennonite Mutual

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Nationwide

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Pekin Insurance

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Progressive

General
Visit Website
Claims
Report Claim
Billing
Bill Pay

Prefer to speak with someone from The Insurance Shop Inc.?
Contact us directly.

Contact Us

Contact Us

Our Odon, IN Office

204 West Main Street
Odon, IN 47562

Our Loogootee, IN Office

200 East Broadway Street
Loogootee, IN 47553

 812-636-2222
Email Us

Get in Touch

Experience the Value of a Home Grown Agency

At The Insurance Shop Inc., we are committed to providing clients with insightful guidance and a broad range of insurance options. Our goal is to foster long-lasting relationships with our clients, supporting their evolving needs over time.

We are licensed in IN, IL, and KY.

© 2025 The Insurance Shop Inc. | Powered by Forge3 ActiveAgency | All rights reserved | Privacy Policy